« Management Improvisation | Main | The Busyness of Information »
September 17, 2008
Business Process vs. Business IT: again?
These frustrate the chances of recognizing "a business process called IT".
On the one hand, this is hard to overcome if people don't say what aspect of IT they mean to identify when they say "IT". An interesting point to put on the matter is that the primary expectation of IT users is actually "process management automation" -- not the same problem to solve as "information management" nor the level-setting about which sanctioned company processes are strategic/tactical/operational.
On the other hand, the word "alignment" itself continues to provoke and refresh the difficulty of reaching "I get it". The more important term to emphasize is not "alignment" but "integration". Imagine that some decision-making sector called "Business" was not integrated with the decision-making sector called "Finance". Since managing IT, like managing Finance, creates and governs a critical dimension of the business operational environment, some businesses cannot be dis-integrated with it and still rationally expect to succeed.
What might be really interesting short-term is to see and compare what stances about "alignment" come from CEOs who are Lawyers or are Technologists as opposed to Finance alumni.
Furthermore, however, as long as the "alignment" banner keeps getting hoisted by analysts and pundits in the trade, they'll keep educating CxOs to think about things in the wrong way. When it comes to IT, CxOs should be working on the management process competency at all levels -- an approach that would make it more obviously the responsibility of CEOs and CFOs to cultivate, not just for CIOs to offer.
Posted by Malcolm Ryder at September 17, 2008 10:04 AM